| Election | Political Party | Elected | Votes | Magnitude |
|---|
| Prince Edward Island (April 2nd, 1873) [PE House of Assembly (1773 - 1890)] | .
Conservative Party of Prince Edward Island | James C. Pope | 0 | 2 |
| Prince Edward Island (December 11th, 1947) | .
Progressive Conservative Party of Prince Edward Island | William Joseph Parnell MacMillan | 2519 | 2 |
| Prince Edward Island (April 26th, 1951) | .
Progressive Conservative Party of Prince Edward Island | William Joseph Parnell MacMillan | 2419 | 2 |
| Prince Edward Island (May 25th, 1955) | .
Liberal Party of Prince Edward Island | Alex A MacIsaac | 2450 | 2 |
| Prince Edward Island (September 1st, 1959) | .
Progressive Conservative Party of Prince Edward Island | Michael Alban Farmer | 3005 | 2 |
| Prince Edward Island (December 10th, 1962) | .
Progressive Conservative Party of Prince Edward Island | Michael Alban Farmer | 2956 | 2 |
| Prince Edward Island (May 30th, 1966) | .
Liberal Party of Prince Edward Island | J Elmer Blanchard | 2925 | 2 |
| Prince Edward Island (May 11th, 1970) | .
Liberal Party of Prince Edward Island | J Elmer Blanchard | 4174 | 2 |
| Prince Edward Island (April 29th, 1974) | .
Liberal Party of Prince Edward Island | George A Proud | 3692 | 2 |
| Prince Edward Island (April 24th, 1978) | .
Liberal Party of Prince Edward Island | George A Proud | 4298 | 2 |
| Prince Edward Island (April 23rd, 1979) | .
Progressive Conservative Party of Prince Edward Island | Wilfred B MacDonald | 4106 | 2 |
| Prince Edward Island (September 27th, 1982) | .
Progressive Conservative Party of Prince Edward Island | Wilfred B MacDonald | 4604 | 2 |
| Prince Edward Island (April 21st, 1986) | .
Liberal Party of Prince Edward Island | Tim B Carroll | 5334 | 2 |
| Prince Edward Island (May 30th, 1989) | .
Liberal Party of Prince Edward Island | Tim B Carroll | 5481 | 2 |
| Prince Edward Island (March 29th, 1993) | .
Liberal Party of Prince Edward Island | Tim B Carroll | 4463 | 2 |
| Prince Edward Island (December 12th, 1900) [PE Legislative Assembly (1893 - 1993)] | .
Liberal Party of Prince Edward Island | George Edward Hughes | 443 | 2 |
| Prince Edward Island (December 7th, 1904) | .
Liberal Party of Prince Edward Island | George Edward Hughes | 497 | 2 |
| Prince Edward Island (January 3rd, 1908) | .
Liberal Party of Prince Edward Island | George Edward Hughes | 0 | 2 |
| Prince Edward Island (September 16th, 1915) | .
Conservative Party of Prince Edward Island | Stephen Rice Jenkins | 442 | 2 |
| Prince Edward Island (July 24th, 1919) | .
Liberal Party of Prince Edward Island | C Gaven Duffy | 742 | 2 |
| Prince Edward Island (July 24th, 1923) | .
Conservative Party of Prince Edward Island | William Joseph Parnell MacMillan | 997 | 2 |
| Prince Edward Island (June 25th, 1927) | .
Conservative Party of Prince Edward Island | William Joseph Parnell MacMillan | 1345 | 2 |
| Prince Edward Island (August 6th, 1931) | .
Conservative Party of Prince Edward Island | William Joseph Parnell MacMillan | 1431 | 2 |
| Prince Edward Island (July 23rd, 1935) | .
Liberal Party of Prince Edward Island | Thomas William Prowse | 3872 | 2 |
| Prince Edward Island (May 18th, 1939) | .
Progressive Conservative Party of Prince Edward Island | William Joseph Parnell MacMillan | 1700 | 2 |
| Prince Edward Island (September 15th, 1943) | .
Progressive Conservative Party of Prince Edward Island | William Joseph Parnell MacMillan | 1375 | 2 |
| Prince Edward Island (January 3rd, 1912) | .
Conservative Party of Prince Edward Island | William S Stewart | 1481 | 2 |
| Prince Edward Island (August 17th, 1876) [PE House of Assembly (1773 - 1890)] | .
Free Schooler | Louis Henry Davies | 989 | 2 |
| Prince Edward Island (November 14th, 1878) [PE Legislative Council (1862 - 1893)] | .
Liberal Party of Prince Edward Island | Thomas W. Dodd | 0 | 1 |
| Prince Edward Island (January 30th, 1890) [PE House of Assembly (1773 - 1890)] | .
Liberal-Conservative | Patrick Blake | 1189 | 2 |
| Prince Edward Island (April 9th, 1879) [PE House of Assembly (1773 - 1890)] | .
Liberal-Conservative | Neil McLeod | 819 | 1 |
| Prince Edward Island (May 8th, 1882) [PE House of Assembly (1773 - 1890)] | .
Liberal-Conservative | Neil McLeod | 1018 | 2 |
| Prince Edward Island (May 30th, 1886) [PE House of Assembly (1773 - 1890)] | .
Liberal-Conservative | Neil McLeod | 1060 | 2 |
| Prince Edward Island (December 13th, 1893) [PE Legislative Assembly (1893 - 1993)] | .
Liberal Party of Prince Edward Island | Lemuel Ezra Prowse | 1118 | 2 |
| Prince Edward Island (July 21st, 1897) [PE Legislative Assembly (1893 - 1993)] | .
Liberal Party of Prince Edward Island | Benjamin Rogers | 467 | 2 |
